ROAD TRIP: Travels with Mary – Experience Amish living in Shipshewana

Above, Amish families in the northeast part of Indiana near Shipshewana traditionally use horses and buggies for transportation in an attempt to live a simpler life. Visitors can book a buggy ride through several commercial vendors in the area. – LaGrange County Convention and Visitors Bureau

by Mary Bohlen

The horse’s hooves clip-clop along the pavement, pulling the black buggy in the early morning mist. The aroma of cinnamon rolls and berry pie wafts from the bakery, tempting all who pass by. Hand-sewn quilts wave gently in the breeze as the vendor sets up shop.

These and other symbols of simpler times beckon visitors to the Shipshewana area in northeast Indiana, the third largest Amish community in the United States. Settled by Dutch and German immigrants 200 years ago, the area is just south of I-80 before the Ohio border.

The area in northeast Indiana is the third largest Amish community in the United States.

Pies of many flavors tempt visitors to the Amish enclave in Shipshewana, Ind. and surrounding areas. – Brent Bohlen photo

Even if you have been to the Arthur/Arcola location of central Illinois, or the Pennsylvania Dutch country, you will find the Amish enclave in Indiana worth the trip.

Start your visit at the Menno-Hof, a free Mennonite-Amish visitors’ center operated by several branches of those faiths in an attempt to tell their history in a non-commercial setting. You will learn about the central beliefs of the 16th Century Anabaptist movement, which spurred the birth of Mennonite, Hutterite and eventually Amish communities. The Amish, the newest of the three major Anabaptist traditions, broke away from the Mennonites in the late 17th century and opt to live today without electricity or motor vehicles in small worship communities.

A key belief among all Anabaptists was that adults should choose to be baptized, which went against the prevailing dictate for baptizing infants and caused problems for the believers in Europe.

The visitors’ center has recreated a dungeon where Anabaptists were persecuted for their faith and a 17th century ship that brought them to America and religious freedom. Also included are a typical meetinghouse and Amish tools, dress and household goods. Other displays highlight modern Mennonite and Amish groups’ commitment to peace and to helping victims of storms, fires and floods.

From May to October, the sprawling flea market bills itself as the ‘the most popular in the Midwest.’ More than 900 vendors peddle everything imaginable, including Amish goods such as quilts.

At the other end of the area’s commercial spectrum is the Shipshewana Auction and Flea Market. The indoor auction buildings host year-round antique, livestock and hay auctions on Wednesdays and horse auctions on Fridays. An annual carriage auction in June features antique and new carriages.

Open on Tuesdays and Wednesdays from May to October, the sprawling flea market bills itself as the “most popular in the Midwest.” More than 900 vendors peddle everything imaginable, including Amish goods such as quilts.

Also open year round are countless small shops and galleries in Shipshewana and surrounding communities. Many shops are closed on Sundays, but on other days you can find locally made wood furniture, yards of fabric, unique musical instruments, artwork and crafts, home décor, jams and jellies, cheese, meat and baked goods.

A trio of Amish buggies makes its way down the road in Shipshawana, Ind. -
A trio of Amish buggies makes their way down the road.  Buggies like this are a common site for visitors of northeast Indiana.  – LaGrange County Convention and Visitors Bureau photo


If you haven’t filled up on goodies from the area bakeries, you can have an Amish lunch or dinner at numerous area restaurants. Family-style meals usually include chicken or roast beef, mashed potatoes, homemade noodles, vegetables, homemade bread and pie.

To work off all that tasty  food, head to the interconnecting MapleHeart Trail, Maple City Greenway and Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, linking Elkhart, Goshen, Middlebury and Shipshewana. The hiking and biking trails, totaling 25 miles, pass through woodlands, pastures, farms, wetlands and parks.

Beth Thornburg, executive director of the LaGrange County Convention and Visitors’ Bureau, recommends canoeing or kayaking the area’s three rivers or 67 lakes.

Learn about history of the Anabaptist movement and the modern day Mennonite and Amish at the free Menno-Hoff Visitors Center in Shipshewana. – Brent Bohlen photo

You also can drive the self-guided Heritage Trail through seven communities and view “quilt gardens,” bloom-filled gardens inspired by quilt patterns, from May 30 to October 1. Maps of the Heritage Trail point out other scenic sites.

Concerts, plays and variety shows entertain visitors at several venues, including the Blue Gate Theater in Shipshewana and Heritage Hall, part of the Essenhaus restaurant and inn complex in Middlebury. Another favorite activity is to take a buggy ride and top it off with dinner in an Amish home.

Area festivals include the Shipshewana Quilt Festival in late June, Old Fashion Farming Days in July and the Shipshewana Fall Crafters Fair in early October. Thornburg says the quilt festival, June 22 – 25 this year, may draw 6,000 visitors for workshops, a quilt shop hop and a juried show. “People submit their quilts from all over the United States, and we’ve had quilters from Germany and Spain,” she says.

Southwest of Shipshewana is Amish Acres in Nappanee, Indiana, a farm turned resort. It features a 100-year-old Amish homestead, lodging, dining, theater, horse drawn buggy rides, shops and an arts and crafts festival in August.

For more information about Shipshewana and surrounding communities, go to The website for the Menno-Hof visitors’ center is Visit for information on the flea market and auction in Shipshewana. Amish Acres’ website is

Mary Bohlen of Springfield is a freelance writer and editor specializing in travel writing. She is a former reporter for United Press International and a long-time journalism professor at the University of Illinois Springfield. With her photographer husband Brent, the couple, Midwestern natives, enjoy exploring new places to visit both near and far.

Each month theYOUjournal features “Travels with Mary” alternately written by Mary Galligan and Mary Bohlen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *